john/claude-engineering-plugin
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

feat(ce-compound): add track-based schema for bug vs knowledge learnings (#445)

Browse Source 
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Trevin Chow
2026-03-29 14:21:13 -07:00
committed by GitHub
parent 44e3e77dc0
commit 739109c03c
7 changed files with 529 additions and 153 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

53
plugins/compound-engineering/skills/ce-compound-refresh/assets/resolution-template.md
View File

@@ -1,3 +1,14 @@
# Resolution Templates
Choose the template matching the problem_type track (see `references/schema.yaml`).
---
## Bug Track Template
Use for: `build_error`, `test_failure`, `runtime_error`, `performance_issue`, `database_issue`, `security_issue`, `ui_bug`, `integration_issue`, `logic_error`
```markdown
---
title: [Clear problem title]
date: [YYYY-MM-DD]
@@ -35,3 +46,45 @@ tags: [keyword-one, keyword-two]
## Related Issues
- [Related docs or issues, if any]
```
---
## Knowledge Track Template
Use for: `best_practice`, `documentation_gap`, `workflow_issue`, `developer_experience`
```markdown
---
title: [Clear, descriptive title]
date: [YYYY-MM-DD]
category: [docs/solutions subdirectory]
module: [Module or area]
problem_type: [schema enum]
component: [schema enum]
severity: [schema enum]
applies_when:
- [Condition where this applies]
tags: [keyword-one, keyword-two]
---
# [Clear, descriptive title]
## Context
[What situation, gap, or friction prompted this guidance]
## Guidance
[The practice, pattern, or recommendation with code examples when useful]
## Why This Matters
[Rationale and impact of following or not following this guidance]
## When to Apply
- [Conditions or situations where this applies]
## Examples
[Concrete before/after or usage examples showing the practice in action]
## Related
- [Related docs or issues, if any]
```

203
plugins/compound-engineering/skills/ce-compound-refresh/references/schema.yaml
View File

@@ -1,15 +1,45 @@
# Documentation schema for learnings written by ce:compound
# Treat this as the canonical frontmatter contract for docs/solutions/.
#
# The schema has two tracks based on problem_type:
# Bug track — problem_type is a defect or failure (build_error, test_failure, etc.)
# Knowledge track — problem_type is guidance or practice (best_practice, workflow_issue, etc.)
#
# Both tracks share the same required core fields. The tracks differ in which
# additional fields are required vs optional (see track_rules below).
# --- Track classification ---------------------------------------------------
tracks:
bug:
description: "Defects, failures, and errors that were diagnosed and fixed"
problem_types:
- build_error
- test_failure
- runtime_error
- performance_issue
- database_issue
- security_issue
- ui_bug
- integration_issue
- logic_error
knowledge:
description: "Best practices, workflow improvements, patterns, and documentation"
problem_types:
- best_practice
- documentation_gap
- workflow_issue
- developer_experience
# --- Fields required by BOTH tracks -----------------------------------------
required_fields:
module:
type: string
description: "Module or area affected by the problem"
description: "Module or area affected"
date:
type: string
pattern: '^\d{4}-\d{2}-\d{2}$'
description: "Date the problem was solved (YYYY-MM-DD)"
description: "Date documented (YYYY-MM-DD)"
problem_type:
type: enum
@@ -27,7 +57,7 @@ required_fields:
- workflow_issue
- best_practice
- documentation_gap
description: "Primary category of the problem"
description: "Primary category — determines track (bug vs knowledge)"
component:
type: enum
@@ -51,49 +81,6 @@ required_fields:
- tooling
description: "Component involved"
symptoms:
type: array[string]
min_items: 1
max_items: 5
description: "Observable symptoms such as errors or broken behavior"
root_cause:
type: enum
values:
- missing_association
- missing_include
- missing_index
- wrong_api
- scope_issue
- thread_violation
- async_timing
- memory_leak
- config_error
- logic_error
- test_isolation
- missing_validation
- missing_permission
- missing_workflow_step
- inadequate_documentation
- missing_tooling
- incomplete_setup
description: "Fundamental technical cause of the problem"
resolution_type:
type: enum
values:
- code_fix
- migration
- config_change
- test_fix
- dependency_update
- environment_setup
- workflow_improvement
- documentation_update
- tooling_addition
- seed_data_update
description: "Type of fix applied"
severity:
type: enum
values:
@@ -103,12 +90,99 @@ required_fields:
- low
description: "Impact severity"
optional_fields:
rails_version:
type: string
pattern: '^\d+\.\d+\.\d+$'
description: "Rails version in X.Y.Z format"
# --- Track-specific rules ----------------------------------------------------
track_rules:
bug:
required:
symptoms:
type: array[string]
min_items: 1
max_items: 5
description: "Observable symptoms such as errors or broken behavior"
root_cause:
type: enum
values:
- missing_association
- missing_include
- missing_index
- wrong_api
- scope_issue
- thread_violation
- async_timing
- memory_leak
- config_error
- logic_error
- test_isolation
- missing_validation
- missing_permission
- missing_workflow_step
- inadequate_documentation
- missing_tooling
- incomplete_setup
description: "Fundamental technical cause of the problem"
resolution_type:
type: enum
values:
- code_fix
- migration
- config_change
- test_fix
- dependency_update
- environment_setup
- workflow_improvement
- documentation_update
- tooling_addition
- seed_data_update
description: "Type of fix applied"
knowledge:
optional:
applies_when:
type: array[string]
max_items: 5
description: "Conditions or situations where this guidance applies"
symptoms:
type: array[string]
max_items: 5
description: "Observable gaps or friction that prompted this guidance (optional for knowledge track)"
root_cause:
type: enum
values:
- missing_association
- missing_include
- missing_index
- wrong_api
- scope_issue
- thread_violation
- async_timing
- memory_leak
- config_error
- logic_error
- test_isolation
- missing_validation
- missing_permission
- missing_workflow_step
- inadequate_documentation
- missing_tooling
- incomplete_setup
description: "Underlying cause, if there is a specific one (optional for knowledge track)"
resolution_type:
type: enum
values:
- code_fix
- migration
- config_change
- test_fix
- dependency_update
- environment_setup
- workflow_improvement
- documentation_update
- tooling_addition
- seed_data_update
description: "Type of change, if applicable (optional for knowledge track)"
# --- Fields optional for BOTH tracks ----------------------------------------
optional_fields:
related_components:
type: array[string]
description: "Other components involved"
@@ -118,10 +192,31 @@ optional_fields:
max_items: 8
description: "Search keywords, lowercase and hyphen-separated"
# --- Fields optional for bug track only -------------------------------------
bug_optional_fields:
rails_version:
type: string
pattern: '^\d+\.\d+\.\d+$'
description: "Rails version in X.Y.Z format. Only relevant for bug-track docs."
# --- Backward compatibility --------------------------------------------------
# Docs created before the track system was introduced may have bug-track
# fields (symptoms, root_cause, resolution_type) on knowledge-type
# problem_types. These are valid legacy docs:
# - Bug-track fields present on a knowledge-track doc are harmless. Do not
# strip them during refresh unless the doc is being rewritten for other reasons.
# - When creating NEW docs, follow the track rules above.
# --- Validation rules --------------------------------------------------------
validation_rules:
- "All required fields must be present"
- "Determine track from problem_type using the tracks section above"
- "All shared required_fields must be present"
- "Bug-track required fields (symptoms, root_cause, resolution_type) must be present on bug-track docs"
- "Knowledge-track docs have no additional required fields beyond the shared ones"
- "Bug-track fields on existing knowledge-track docs are harmless (see backward compatibility note)"
- "Track-specific optional fields may be included but are not required"
- "Enum fields must match allowed values exactly"
- "symptoms must be a YAML array with 1-5 items"
- "Array fields must respect min_items/max_items when specified"
- "date must match YYYY-MM-DD format"
- "rails_version, if provided, must match X.Y.Z format"
- "rails_version, if provided, must match X.Y.Z format and only applies to bug-track docs"
- "tags should be lowercase and hyphen-separated"

63
plugins/compound-engineering/skills/ce-compound-refresh/references/yaml-schema.md
View File

@@ -7,24 +7,57 @@ Use this file as the quick reference for:
- enum values
- validation expectations
- category mapping
- track classification (bug vs knowledge)
## Required Fields
## Tracks
- **module**: Module or area affected by the problem
The `problem_type` determines which **track** applies. Each track has different required and optional fields.
| Track | problem_types | Description |
|-------|--------------|-------------|
| **Bug** | `build_error`, `test_failure`, `runtime_error`, `performance_issue`, `database_issue`, `security_issue`, `ui_bug`, `integration_issue`, `logic_error` | Defects and failures that were diagnosed and fixed |
| **Knowledge** | `best_practice`, `documentation_gap`, `workflow_issue`, `developer_experience` | Practices, patterns, workflow improvements, and documentation |
## Required Fields (both tracks)
- **module**: Module or area affected
- **date**: ISO date in `YYYY-MM-DD`
- **problem_type**: One of `build_error`, `test_failure`, `runtime_error`, `performance_issue`, `database_issue`, `security_issue`, `ui_bug`, `integration_issue`, `logic_error`, `developer_experience`, `workflow_issue`, `best_practice`, `documentation_gap`
- **problem_type**: One of the values listed in the Tracks table above
- **component**: One of `rails_model`, `rails_controller`, `rails_view`, `service_object`, `background_job`, `database`, `frontend_stimulus`, `hotwire_turbo`, `email_processing`, `brief_system`, `assistant`, `authentication`, `payments`, `development_workflow`, `testing_framework`, `documentation`, `tooling`
- **symptoms**: YAML array with 1-5 concrete symptoms
- **root_cause**: One of `missing_association`, `missing_include`, `missing_index`, `wrong_api`, `scope_issue`, `thread_violation`, `async_timing`, `memory_leak`, `config_error`, `logic_error`, `test_isolation`, `missing_validation`, `missing_permission`, `missing_workflow_step`, `inadequate_documentation`, `missing_tooling`, `incomplete_setup`
- **resolution_type**: One of `code_fix`, `migration`, `config_change`, `test_fix`, `dependency_update`, `environment_setup`, `workflow_improvement`, `documentation_update`, `tooling_addition`, `seed_data_update`
- **severity**: One of `critical`, `high`, `medium`, `low`
## Optional Fields
## Bug Track Fields
Required:
- **symptoms**: YAML array with 1-5 observable symptoms (errors, broken behavior)
- **root_cause**: One of `missing_association`, `missing_include`, `missing_index`, `wrong_api`, `scope_issue`, `thread_violation`, `async_timing`, `memory_leak`, `config_error`, `logic_error`, `test_isolation`, `missing_validation`, `missing_permission`, `missing_workflow_step`, `inadequate_documentation`, `missing_tooling`, `incomplete_setup`
- **resolution_type**: One of `code_fix`, `migration`, `config_change`, `test_fix`, `dependency_update`, `environment_setup`, `workflow_improvement`, `documentation_update`, `tooling_addition`, `seed_data_update`
## Knowledge Track Fields
No additional required fields beyond the shared ones. All fields below are optional:
- **applies_when**: Conditions or situations where this guidance applies
- **symptoms**: Observable gaps or friction that prompted this guidance
- **root_cause**: Underlying cause, if there is a specific one
- **resolution_type**: Type of change, if applicable
## Optional Fields (both tracks)
- **rails_version**: Rails version in `X.Y.Z` format
- **related_components**: Other components involved
- **tags**: Search keywords, lowercase and hyphen-separated
## Optional Fields (bug track only)
- **rails_version**: Rails version in `X.Y.Z` format
## Backward Compatibility
Docs created before the track system may have `symptoms`/`root_cause`/`resolution_type` on knowledge-type problem_types. These are valid legacy docs:
- Bug-track fields present on a knowledge-track doc are harmless. Do not strip them during refresh unless the doc is being rewritten for other reasons.
- When creating **new** docs, follow the track rules above.
## Category Mapping
- `build_error` -> `docs/solutions/build-errors/`
@@ -43,8 +76,12 @@ Use this file as the quick reference for:
## Validation Rules
1. All required fields must be present.
2. Enum fields must match the allowed values exactly.
3. `symptoms` must be a YAML array with 1-5 items.
4. `date` must match `YYYY-MM-DD`.
5. `rails_version`, if present, must match `X.Y.Z`.
1. Determine the track from `problem_type` using the Tracks table.
2. All shared required fields must be present.
3. Bug-track required fields (`symptoms`, `root_cause`, `resolution_type`) must be present on bug-track docs.
4. Knowledge-track docs have no additional required fields beyond the shared ones.
5. Bug-track fields on existing knowledge-track docs are harmless (see Backward Compatibility).
6. Enum fields must match the allowed values exactly.
7. Array fields must respect min/max item counts.
8. `date` must match `YYYY-MM-DD`.
9. `rails_version`, if present, must match `X.Y.Z` and only applies to bug-track docs.